Larry Hoover's Clemency Fight: Will Illinois Let Him Go?

Trump commuted Larry Hoover's federal life sentence in 2025, but the Gangster Disciples founder is still serving 150 to 200 years in Illinois. The petition, the opposition, the April hearing, and why Gov. Pritzker has no deadline to decide.

Share
An empty dim hearing room at dusk with three empty chairs behind a long wooden table, a single blank folder on it, and the Chicago skyline in the tall windows

Part of Chicago Gangs: ← Back to series hub

Not yet. As of November 4, 2026, Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker has not announced a decision on Larry Hoover's request for clemency. The Illinois Prisoner Review Board heard the case on April 7, 2026, and by mid-May it had sent the governor its recommendation. That recommendation is confidential, and state law gives the governor no deadline to act on it.1 Until he does, the 75-year-old founder of the Gangster Disciples stays in custody on a 150-to-200-year sentence for a murder committed in 1973.1 2

That is the strange position he is in. In May 2025 President Donald Trump wiped out the federal life sentence that had kept him in a Colorado supermax for most of three decades.5 4 It turned out to be only half the lock. The other half belongs to Illinois, and the man holding the key hasn't turned it.

Quick facts

  • Who: Larry Hoover, 75, co-founder of the Gangster Disciples2
  • State sentence: 150 to 200 years for ordering the 1973 killing of William "Pooky" Young, 193
  • Federal sentence: life, from a 1997 conviction; commuted by Trump in May 20255
  • Where he is: in Illinois Department of Corrections custody, at a location authorities won't disclose1 2
  • Clemency status: petition filed October 22, 2025; hearing April 7, 2026; recommendation with the governor since May 2026; no decision announced as of November 4, 20264 1

Two Sentences, One Commutation

He was already serving his Illinois murder sentence when federal prosecutors indicted him in 1995 for running the gang's drug trade from inside state prison. A jury convicted him on 40 counts in 1997, and Judge Harry Leinenweber gave him the mandatory life term. "Sometimes I think they are too draconian," the judge said of the sentencing guidelines. "But in this case, I agree with them 100%."5 The case rested in part on his own voice: he was recorded on a hidden microphone directing the gang's street operations while he was in state custody.2 The full story of how he built that operation is in our history of the Gangster Disciples.

For years his lawyers tried to shorten the federal term under the First Step Act. Prosecutors fought back hard. In 2020 then-U.S. Attorney John Lausch told a judge it would be a "miscarriage of justice to reduce [Hoover's] sentence in any way, shape or form."4 At a 2024 hearing U.S. District Judge John Robert Blakey asked the defense lawyer point-blank, "How many other murders is he responsible for?" When she said she couldn't put a number on it, he asked, "So many we can't count?"5

Blakey never got to rule. Trump's one-page order, issued in late May 2025, declared the federal sentence served "with no further fines, restitution, probation or other conditions" and told the Bureau of Prisons to release him immediately.5 The commutation ended a campaign that had drawn celebrity attention for years; Kanye West met Trump in the Oval Office in 2018 to argue for his release.3

"Release" meant something narrower than it sounded. Within days he left the federal supermax in Florence, Colorado, and went straight into state custody to serve the Illinois sentence. Colorado prison officials confirmed he was being held in their system under the Interstate Corrections Compact, while Illinois said he remained under its jurisdiction.6 Authorities now decline to say where he is, citing security concerns.2

The Sentence Illinois Doesn't Hand Out Anymore

The state case goes back to 1973. According to Cook County State's Attorney Eileen O'Neill Burke, he ordered the killing of William Young because he believed the 19-year-old was stealing from the gang's Englewood drug stash houses. Hoover and fellow gang member Andrew Howard were both sentenced to 150 to 200 years. Both were also suspected in the fatal shooting of a man who had cooperated with police in the Young investigation.3

That sentence is a relic. Hoover is one of 33 elderly "C-number" inmates in Illinois, people given indeterminate sentences before the state switched to fixed prison terms in 1978. C-number inmates still get regular parole hearings, and those hearings are separate from clemency.1 He has been going to them for decades and losing.4 When the board turned him down in 2022, the vote was 10 to 1. Its written decision cited his role in a deadly 1978 riot at Pontiac prison and a decoding dictionary found in his cell in 2017, and concluded that "Hoover's past continues to impact his present and will forever affect his future."7 Federal prosecutors had argued that he used coded messages hidden in a dictionary to secretly promote an underling.5 Another parole request, in 2023, was also denied.3

Howard walked out on parole in 1992.3 Hoover's supporters treat that as the heart of the unfairness. "He supposedly ordered a murder. The murderer has been released in the '90s and we're still finding a way to keep him incarcerated," state Sen. Willie Preston said.4 Prosecutors read the same facts the other way around: Burke wrote that he still calls Howard the "principal actor," even though he led their faction, and that he doesn't accept full responsibility for the killing.3

The Petition: "I Am Tired"

His lawyers filed for clemency with Pritzker on October 22, 2025, five months after the federal commutation.4 The petition is part legal brief, part plea. It says he had three heart attacks after leaving federal prison and was working a kitchen line at the Colorado State Penitentiary, where attorney Justin Moore said he was the oldest worker "by a gap of 10 to 15 years."4 "To deny clemency now is not a neutral act," Moore wrote. "It is a willful decision to let a 74-year-old man with significant health challenges die in a cage."4

The filing says he has renounced his ties to the Gangster Disciples and calls his continued imprisonment a "slow, state-sanctioned death sentence." Its most quoted line is about where he came from: "Hoover did not create the fire. He grew up in it." It also quotes him directly: "I just want to come home and be with my family. I am tired."3 According to the petition, he wants to work with violence interruption groups and teach at the university level.4

The list of backers is long. The petition names Chance the Rapper, Greg Mathis, former U.S. Rep. Bobby Rush, U.S. Rep. Jonathan Jackson, the late Rev. Jesse Jackson Sr. and the Rev. Al Sharpton, among others.4 Former U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan, who runs the anti-violence group Chicago CRED, wrote that he would be "more than welcome to help us" if released.3 The Rev. Michael Pfleger of St. Sabina Church said he sent a letter of support, though he added that he doesn't think the 75-year-old could "come out here and solve the gang problem."1 His son has called him a political prisoner.7 That is his family's view, not a finding by any court.

The Case Against

The opposition is just as organized. On December 29, 2025, Burke sent the review board a letter objecting to his first request for executive clemency. "Both things can be and are true," she wrote: Chicago was "ravaged by misguided public policies and disinvestment," and he "took advantage of the system's failures and further ravaged Chicago's neighborhoods" by building the Gangster Disciples.3 That letter marked a shift for her office. Her predecessor, Kim Foxx, had stopped offering opinions on parole in 2021.3

The core of the prosecution's argument is that age doesn't neutralize a man who never did his own dirty work. Authorities credit the gang with a $100-million-a-year drug operation and more than 30,000 members in Chicago and around the country.2 At the April hearing, Assistant State's Attorney Enrique Abraham said his "criminal acts have almost always been carried out vicariously through surrogates," which is why, in his view, an aging 75-year-old can still be a public danger. His closing line was short: "William Young never got a second chance."2

The April Hearing

The board heard the case on April 7, 2026, in downtown Chicago. The petitioner wasn't there. Dozens of supporters were, and some raised their hands when asked to identify themselves. A three-member panel (Matthew Coates, Carmen Terrones and Jeffrey Grubbs) presided and gave no hint of how it was leaning.2

The most surprising witness was John Gleeson, the former federal prosecutor who went after Gambino boss John Gotti and later became a federal judge. He is now on the defense team. Hoover had "grown up," Gleeson told the panel, and "Larry Hoover poses no risk of danger to the community."2 His wife, Winndye, said he had missed his children's graduations. "He's not a monster," she said. "His family loves him."2 Moore acknowledged his client's past ("We are not here to excuse what happened in Mr. Hoover's life") and pointed out that the sentence was handed down under a system Illinois has since abandoned.2

The board deciding all this was itself rebuilt recently. In 2024 two members quit after the board approved the release of a man who went on to stab his former girlfriend and kill her son. Pritzker signed a law reforming the board, and as of April 2026 it had nine members and six vacancies.2 On May 14 a board spokesperson confirmed that all recommendations from the April docket, Hoover's included, had gone to the governor.1

How Illinois Clemency Actually Works

The review board only advises. The decision belongs to one person. Article V, Section 12 of the Illinois Constitution says the governor "may grant reprieves, commutations and pardons, after conviction, for all offenses on such terms as he thinks proper." The legislature can regulate how people apply, but not the power itself.8

Illinois has seen how far that power reaches. On January 10, 2003, Gov. George Ryan announced "blanket clemency" for everyone on the state's death row and commuted the sentences of more than 160 inmates. When the attorney general challenged parts of it, the Illinois Supreme Court upheld the commutations and repeated an old line from its own case law: the governor's clemency acts "can be controlled only by his conscience and his sense of public duty."8 The same court added a hope that governors would use the power "to prevent miscarriages of justice in individual cases."8

So there is no appeal if Pritzker says no, and no court can make him say yes. Two separate tracks stay open regardless. He can keep asking the review board for parole, which it can grant without the governor's formal input.3 And Illinois sets no limit on how many times a person can apply for clemency.9

What the Governor's Record Shows

Nobody outside the governor's office knows what the board recommended. The public numbers do show how rarely sentence commutations happen right now. Ina Silvergleid, a clemency attorney who regularly requests data from the review board, counted 173 clemency decisions by Pritzker in 2025: 73 pardons, one commutation and 99 denials. Most of the denials (72) went to people asking for shorter sentences, and murder and sex offenses made up 63.6% of the commutation denials.9 She counted 96 commutations in his first term (2019 to 2022) and 16 from 2023 through 2025.9 By May 1, 2026, he had granted four pardons for the year and, by her count, denied no petitions at all.10 She also found that he doesn't rule on petitions in the order they arrive.9 10

None of that predicts Hoover's outcome. His case is not typical in any way, and the governor's office has said only that he "takes the clemency process very seriously," weighing the facts and the views of both petitioners and victims' families.4 What the numbers do show is that a commutation for a murder conviction would be a rare move by these numbers, and that waiting a long time for an answer is normal.

What Happens Next

There are three realistic outcomes, and one of them is the status quo.

  • Grant. A commutation could shorten the sentence or end it. The constitution lets the governor attach "such terms as he thinks proper," so a release with conditions is possible.8 His lawyers say he wants to return to Chicago and his family.4
  • Denial. He stays in prison, keeps his parole hearings, and can file again.1 9
  • Silence. No deadline means the recommendation can simply sit on the desk.1 As of today it has been there for nearly six months.

Back in May 2025, a former longtime chairman of the review board, Jorge Montes, predicted Trump's commutation would turn out to be "a pyrrhic victory." "At the end of the day," he told NBC Chicago, Hoover "isn't going anywhere."7 Seventeen months later that prediction is still holding, though the clemency petition is the most serious test of it so far.

FAQ

Is Larry Hoover out of prison?
No. Trump commuted his federal life sentence in May 2025, but he is still serving his Illinois sentence for the 1973 murder of William Young. As of November 4, 2026, no clemency decision has been announced.5 1

Did Trump pardon Larry Hoover?
Not technically. It was a commutation, which swaps a punishment for a lesser one: the federal sentence was declared served. It had no effect on his separate state sentence.5 8 2

Where is Larry Hoover being held?
He is in Illinois Department of Corrections custody. He was first held in Colorado's state system under an interstate compact, and authorities now decline to give his location for security reasons.6 1 2

Why was Andrew Howard paroled and Hoover wasn't?
Both got the same 150-to-200-year sentence. Howard was paroled in 1992. The board has repeatedly found that releasing Hoover would not be in the interest of public safety, citing his later conduct in prison.3 7

When will Pritzker decide?
Nobody knows. The board's recommendation went to him in May 2026, and Illinois law sets no deadline.1

For the alliance system Hoover helped build inside Illinois prisons, read Folk Nation vs People Nation. For the wider cast of men who turned the drug trade into empires, browse our American drug kingpins series.

William Young was killed 53 years ago. In that time Hoover has outlived the federal sentence that was supposed to keep him locked up for life. What's left is one Illinois sentence from 1973, one man with the power to end it, and a deadline that doesn't exist.

Part of Chicago Gangs: ← Back to series hub

─────────

Sources:

  1. Main, Frank, Tina Sfondeles and Tom Schuba. "Gangster Disciples founder Larry Hoover's bid for freedom is now in Gov. JB Pritzker's hands." Chicago Sun-Times, May 14, 2026. suntimes.com
  2. Main, Frank. "Gangster Disciples founder Larry Hoover has wife, ex-NY mob prosecutor push parole board to free him." Chicago Sun-Times, April 7, 2026. suntimes.com
  3. Main, Frank. "Ex-Gangster Disciples boss Larry Hoover's freedom bid should be rejected, Cook County top prosecutor says." Chicago Sun-Times, January 21, 2026. suntimes.com
  4. Sfondeles, Tina, and Jon Seidel. "Drug kingpin Larry Hoover asks Gov. JB Pritzker for freedom." Chicago Sun-Times, October 22, 2025. suntimes.com
  5. Meisner, Jason. "Trump commutes federal life sentence for former Gangster Disciples boss Larry Hoover." Chicago Tribune, via Corrections1, May 29, 2025. corrections1.com
  6. Seidel, Jon, and David Struett. "Larry Hoover, Robert Crimo III have Illinois prison sentences to serve, but where?" Chicago Sun-Times, May 30, 2025. suntimes.com
  7. Goudie, Chuck, and Katy Smyser. "What are murderous Chicago gang boss Larry Hoover's chances of parole?" NBC Chicago, May 29, 2025. nbcchicago.com
  8. People ex rel. Madigan v. Snyder, Illinois Supreme Court, January 23, 2004 (quoting Ill. Const. 1970, art. V, sec. 12). law.justia.com
  9. Silvergleid, Ina. "The Wait Goes On: Illinois' Clemency Report Card for 2025." A Bridge Forward, January 23, 2026. abridgeforward.com
  10. Silvergleid, Ina. "Delayed Gratification Describes Length of Time It Takes to Obtain a Clemency Decision in Illinois." A Bridge Forward, May 5, 2026. abridgeforward.com