Lizzie Borden: What Really Happened in Fall River, 1892
Andrew and Abby Borden were killed on August 4, 1892. Lizzie was tried and acquitted in 1893. The morning, the evidence, the exclusions, the verdict, and the rhyme that outran the record.
On the morning of August 4, 1892, someone killed Andrew Borden and his wife, Abby, with a hatchet inside their house at 92 Second Street in Fall River, Massachusetts, roughly an hour and a half apart. Andrew's 32-year-old daughter Lizzie was arrested a week later, tried in June 1893, and acquitted after the jury deliberated for about an hour. Nobody else was ever tried. The rhyme says forty whacks; the record says about nineteen on Abby and ten or eleven on Andrew.1
This page walks through what happened, what the courtroom actually heard, and where the legend drifted from the record. Legends stay labeled as legends. Theories stay labeled as theories.
Quick facts
- Victims: Andrew J. Borden, 69, a wealthy Fall River businessman who never made a show of his money, and Abby Durfee Gray Borden, 64, his second wife and Lizzie's stepmother.1
- When: Thursday, August 4, 1892, between roughly 9 and 11:15 a.m.3
- Charged: Lizzie Borden, arrested August 11, 1892, indicted December 2, 1892.3
- Trial: June 5 to 20, 1893, in New Bedford. Verdict: not guilty.2,3
- Weapon: A hatchet, not an ax. No weapon was tied to her at trial.1,2
The morning in the house
The household that Thursday was small: Andrew and Abby, Lizzie, and the family's 26-year-old Irish maid, Bridget Sullivan. Lizzie's older sister Emma was away, about 15 miles from Fall River.1,3 Abby was in the second-floor guest room, apparently making the bed, when she was killed.2 Bridget was outside washing windows at the time.1
Andrew came home from his morning business rounds and was attacked in the sitting room, apparently while he napped. Bridget was resting in her third-floor room.1,2 She called for her. A neighbor, Adelaide Churchill, looked out her window and saw Lizzie, visibly upset, clinging to the screen door. "Oh, Mrs. Churchill, do come over," Lizzie said. "Someone has killed father."2
Churchill went upstairs with Bridget and found Abby.2 Neighbors and passers-by had heard nothing, and no one had seen a suspect come or go.1 Within hours, police had arrested a Portuguese immigrant who was innocent, a sign of how fast the town's assumptions about who could have done this went to work.1
The rhyme versus the record
The famous rhyme gets three things wrong:
- "Her mother": Abby was Lizzie's stepmother. Lizzie's own mother, Sarah, died in 1863, when Lizzie was two.3
- "An ax": The suspected weapon was a hatchet, a smaller and lighter tool.1
- "Forty whacks": The count was about 19 blows for Abby and 10 or 11 for Andrew.1
The sequence is right: Abby first, Andrew about an hour and a half later.1 As for where the rhyme came from, nobody knows who wrote it. The earliest print appearance researchers have found so far is a February 15, 1894 item in an Ohio newspaper, eight months after the acquittal, and that version says twenty and twenty-one, not forty.5 The forty-whacks version is documented in Edmund Pearson's 1924 essay on the case.5 Borden House tour guide and historian Megan Alves told the Boston Globe in 2026 that the rhythm matches the playground song "Ta-ra-ra Boom-de-ay," that a lesser-known second verse assumes guilt ("On the gallows she will swing"), and that historians generally favor the theory that a newspaperman wrote it to sell papers.6
Why police settled on her
There was no motive that anyone could prove and no witness. What police had was a set of problems with her story.
Her answers moved. She told police she had been getting fishing gear in the barn, or standing in the yard, or picking pears.2 Her inquest testimony on August 9 to 11 wandered the same way. Her supporters pointed out that the family doctor, Seabury Bowen, had prescribed a double dose of morphine to help her sleep, and that police questioning in 1892 was often blind to the effects of trauma.1,2,3 Her critics saw evasion.
The prussic acid. Eli Bence claimed Lizzie had come into D.R. Smith's drugstore the day before the murders and tried to buy prussic acid, a deadly poison.3 The defense said he had misidentified her.1 The judges later kept the story out of the trial, because prosecutors had not refuted that the poison could be used innocently.1,4
The burned dress. The most damaging new detail came late. Alice Russell, Lizzie's close friend, told the grand jury on December 1 that on the Sunday after the murders she watched Lizzie burn a dress in the cast-iron coal stove.1,3 The grand jury indicted Lizzie the next day.3 At trial, Emma testified that the dress was old, faded and stained, and that it was destroyed for that reason.2
The family money. Historian Joseph Conforti notes that she, still living at home at 32, longed to live on "the Hill," Fall River's fashionable district, and knew her father could afford the move.1 That is a motive theory, not a proven one.
She spent about nine months in a cell measuring 9.5 by 7.5 feet while the case moved from preliminary hearing to grand jury to trial.1 For the wider story of how America locked people up before trial, see our prisons hub.
The trial: June 5 to 20, 1893
The prosecution was led by Bristol County District Attorney Hosea Knowlton, joined by William H. Moody, who later became a U.S. Supreme Court justice.2,7 The defense team included Andrew Jennings, the Bordens' longtime lawyer, and George D. Robinson, a former governor of Massachusetts.2 Three judges presided.2
The prosecution's problem was simple: no murder weapon and no blood. A Harvard chemist found none on two axes and two hatchets that police took from the cellar. Police also found a hatchet head with a broken handle there, and the break looked fresh. It was suspected as the weapon, but its role stayed contested.1,7 The dress she turned over to police carried only a tiny spot of blood on the hem.1 Jennings told the jury there was "not a spot of blood" and "not a weapon connected with her."2
The judges then narrowed the case further. They kept out Lizzie's inquest testimony, on June 12, and the prussic acid story, on June 14.4 Women could not serve on juries then, so she faced an all-male jury, with Fall River itself excluded from the jury pool. About half the jurors were farmers.1,2 Lizzie, dressed in black and holding a bouquet and a fan, presented herself as the opposite of what a hatchet killer was imagined to be.1
Knowlton delivered a closing argument that ran about five hours.1 Asked how a killer could have avoided getting spattered, he leaned on the stereotypes of his day: "You are neither murderers nor women," he told the jurors, arguing that only a woman's cunning could explain a killer who left no blood.2 The defendant, who had not testified at trial, said only: "I am innocent. I leave it to my counsel to speak for me."2
Justice Justin Dewey then told the jury that if the evidence left them with suspicion, "or even a strong probability of guilt," their duty was to acquit.2 On June 20, 1893, they did, after about an hour. A conviction would have meant execution.2
Acquitted is not exonerated
This is the part the legend always skips. A not-guilty verdict means the state failed to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. It does not mean the jury, or history, decided she was innocent. Cases like the ones on our famous exonerations page are different: there, new evidence showed the person did not do it. In the Borden case, nothing like that ever emerged for Lizzie, and nothing convincing ever emerged against anyone else.
The alternatives are theories, and they have stayed theories:
- Emma. Some writers have suggested she could have slipped back or helped, but she was away at Fairhaven, about 15 miles off, and was never charged.2,7
- An outsider. Accounts of a stranger seen fleeing Fall River were never fully run down, and the man arrested on day one was innocent. No outsider was ever charged.1,2
- John Morse. Lizzie's uncle was a guest the night before. Police had a patrolman follow him, but he was never charged.3,4
Historians still argue over all of it. What the record supports is narrower than the legend: two people were killed in an occupied house in broad daylight, and the one person tried for it was found not guilty.1,2
After the verdict
Two months after the verdict, Lizzie and Emma moved to a large Victorian house on the Hill. Lizzie later named it Maplecroft and began calling herself Lizbeth.1,7 Many people, including some at her church, shunned her. Neighborhood children played pranks on her.1 The sisters quarreled in 1904, Emma left in 1905, and they never saw each other again.1 Lizzie died on June 1, 1927. Emma died nine days later, on June 10.4 Both were buried in the plot with their father and stepmother.1
The story never stopped selling. The press circulated it in 1893 and it is still moving: Netflix released Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story on September 17, 2026, and the rhyme went back into circulation.6 It belongs on the same Gilded Age shelf as H.H. Holmes, another legend that grew in newspapers and outran the facts. More true-crime profiles live in our serial killers and cults section.
The honest ending is the unsatisfying one. A jury looked at a thin case and acquitted, a town never forgave her, and a playground rhyme made the verdict sound like a punchline. The record gives us a mystery, not a confession.
Sources
- Joseph Conforti, "How Lizzie Borden Got Away With Murder," Smithsonian Magazine / Zócalo Public Square, smithsonianmag.com.
- Stephen G. Christianson, "Lizzie Borden Trial: 1893," Great American Trials, encyclopedia.com.
- Kat Koorey, "Chronologies" (legal chronology and Lizzie Borden's inquest timeline), Lizzie Andrew Borden, lizzieandrewborden.com.
- Kat Koorey, "June/July Timeline," The Hatchet: Journal of Lizzie Borden Studies (2004), lizzieandrewborden.com.
- Stefani Koorey, "The Doggerel Discovered," Mondo Lizzie Borden, Jan. 1, 2017, lizzieandrewborden.com.
- "Where did the Lizzie Borden '40 whacks' rhyme come from?," The Boston Globe, Sept. 17, 2026, bostonglobe.com.
- "Lizzie Borden," Wikipedia (hatchet head found in the basement, Emma's Fairhaven alibi, William H. Moody, Maplecroft), en.wikipedia.org.