The Black Dahlia: Elizabeth Short's Unsolved 1947 Murder

Elizabeth Short, 22, was found bisected in a Los Angeles lot in January 1947 and nicknamed the Black Dahlia. The timeline, the suspect theories and the cold case in 2026.

Share
A foggy 1940s Los Angeles residential street at dawn with a vacant weedy lot, a wooden utility pole and a single lit streetlamp

Part of American Crimes: Crime and Media

The Black Dahlia is the nickname given to Elizabeth Short, 22, whose bisected body was found in a vacant lot in Los Angeles on January 15, 1947.1 The murder remains unsolved.2 6 The nickname came from the press and a 1946 movie.1 The Los Angeles Times says myths "continue to swirl" around Short.3

Quick facts

  • Victim: Elizabeth "Betty" Short, age 22, from Massachusetts2
  • Found: January 15, 1947, in a vacant lot on Norton Avenue near 39th Street, Leimert Park, Los Angeles2 4
  • Identified: by the FBI from fingerprints on file since 19431
  • Last known to see her alive: Robert "Red" Manley, a salesman who was arrested January 19 and released a day later2
  • Suspects: 192 investigated and dismissed by October 1949, according to the grand jury2
  • Status: unsolved2 6

Who Was Elizabeth Short?

She was a young woman from Massachusetts who drifted around Southern California and lied often about where she had been and what she did.2 The Times reported in 2024 that she "came to Southern California not to pursue film stardom but a paramour," and that she had no permanent address in January 1947.3 According to Larry Harnisch, a retired Times copy editor who has researched the case since the late 1990s, Short had no acting training, no Central Casting registration and a Boston accent that would have limited her roles.3

That is a long way from the legend of the doomed starlet. Anne Redding of Santa Barbara City College calls Short "literally homeless" and "a high-risk victim in a high-risk situation."3

Why Is She Called the Black Dahlia?

The name plays on The Blue Dahlia, a 1946 film, and on her black hair and dark clothes.1 2 The FBI says the press gave her the nickname.1 The Times adds a caution: there is no proof Short ever knew the name.3

How Was the Body Found and Identified?

A mother walking with her child spotted the body on the morning of January 15, 1947, and reportedly took it for a mannequin.1 The body had been cut in half at the waist, and there was no blood at the scene, indicating she had been killed elsewhere.1

Identification was fast for the era. The Examiner, a Los Angeles paper, sent her prints to the FBI to learn her name.3 The Bureau received them over a "Soundphoto" machine and identified her in 56 minutes.1 Her prints appeared twice in the FBI's collection: first on a January 1943 application for a clerk's job at the commissary of the Army's Camp Cooke, then after a Santa Barbara arrest for underage drinking seven months later.1

What Happened in the Investigation?

DateEvent
Jan. 15, 1947Body found; FBI identifies Short from fingerprints1
Jan. 19-20, 1947Robert "Red" Manley arrested, then released a day later2
Jan. 24, 1947Postal inspectors intercept an envelope with Short's address book and papers and a note made of cut-out headlines: "Here is Dahlia's belongings. Letter to follow."2
Jan. 28, 1947Daniel Voorhees gives police the first demonstrably false confession2
Oct. 1949Grand jury asks the district attorney's office to examine the police handling of the case; it concludes "the murder remained unsolved through a lack of evidence and not because of police misconduct"2
2003Steve Hodel publishes a book accusing his late father4

Detectives never learned where Short had been in the week before she was found.2 More letters followed the envelope, but none could be conclusively tied to the killer.2 The FBI says it searched for a match to fingerprints on an anonymous letter that may have come from the killer, but the prints were not in FBI files.1 Agents were also asked to check medical students at USC, on early suspicion that the killer may have had dissection skills.1 The FBI's released case file documents the Bureau's assistance to the LAPD in 1947 and 1948.7

Who Are the Main Suspects in the Murder?

No suspect has ever been proven. Books have proposed many suspects. David Lambkin, a retired detective who examined the case as head of the LAPD Cold Case Unit in 2001, said of the suspects the books propose, "Very few have anything going for them."3 Harnisch put it this way: "People want this grab bag of noir tropes."3

  • Dr. George Hodel (theory). In 2003, a retired LAPD homicide detective named his own late father, a physician who died in 1999, as the killer.4 Asked whether he would spend money reopening the case, District Attorney Steve Cooley answered, "Not a nickel."4 The file Times columnist Steve Lopez read showed that D.A. detective Frank Jemison had compiled a list of 22 suspects that included George Hodel, and that, although Hodel allegedly said, "They'll never be able to prove I did that murder," Jemison wrote that transcripts from bugging Hodel's house "tend to prove his innocence."4 Lopez wrote: “Maybe George Hodel was just taunting the police, knowing his house was bugged.”4 He also found a second file with a bugging transcript in which Hodel is recorded saying "Supposin' I did kill the Black Dahlia."4 Harnisch calls the theory "crap" and "fabricated."3
  • Leslie Dillon. A bellhop booked on suspicion in January 1949 and named as the killer in Piu Eatwell's book Black Dahlia Red Rose.3 Harnisch says Dillon was in San Francisco when it happened.3
  • Bugsy Siegel (theory). Donald Wolfe's book The Black Dahlia Files names the gangster Siegel as the killer, working for Times publisher Norman Chandler, who allegedly got Short pregnant; the Times records Harnisch's verdict on that theory as "Ridiculous, painfully stupid."3 Our piece on the gangsters who built Las Vegas covers Siegel's own career.
  • Dr. Walter Bayley (theory). Harnisch's own candidate: a 66-year-old surgeon with a brain lesion whose estranged wife lived a block away from where the body was found.3 Harnisch says: "He's not a perfect suspect, but he checks more boxes than anyone else."3 Lambkin called Harnisch's theory his favorite.3

Lambkin told the Times that almost no physical evidence remained by the time he reviewed the file, and that a solution is unlikely.3

Is the Case Still Open?

Yes, as a cold case, according to two 2026 reports. In October 2026, Los Angeles magazine quoted retired LAPD Commander Robert Taylor, who works with a reinvestigation team and spoke on his own behalf, saying the team did not ask LAPD for a copy of the autopsy report because it recognized the case was "still an ongoing investigation, a cold case."6 A May 2026 Fox News report shows the LAPD still taking in new claims.5 Fox reported that Detective Marty Mojarro, one of two cold case investigators who have inherited the case, called it "probably one of the most difficult cases, realistically."5 He received what examiner Alex Baber says is the 1943 fingerprint card of Short's ex-boyfriend Marvin Margolis, though he would not say what else the LAPD may or may not have to compare it with.5 Fox said police records Baber had provided place Margolis, a Navy veteran who dated Short, among 22 persons of interest in 1951.5 Margolis was never charged and has since died.5 Baber says the evidence may link Margolis to Short's murder and to the Zodiac Killer; Fox reported that Mojarro said that claim still needs vetting but warrants further investigation.5 Mojarro told Fox: "We don't have live witnesses to interview."5 Fox reported no comparison result.

Separately, Los Angeles magazine, writing in October 2026 about what it calls one of the city's "most infamous unsolved cases," reported that the producer of a forthcoming docuseries, Kimberly Lupini, says the county Medical Examiner's office answered a request with, "We cannot find the Elizabeth Short file," even though, in the magazine's words, "evidence suggests at least part of it was still there decades after her death."6 The magazine says: "That doesn’t necessarily mean the report no longer exists."6 Lupini's team also runs a "Justice for Elizabeth" petition, which the magazine says has passed 10,000 signatures and calls on the LAPD to release the complete autopsy report.6 These are the team's claims.

What Do People Get Wrong About Elizabeth Short's Story?

Popular versionWhat the record says
She was a Hollywood starlet.Harnisch says she had no acting training and no Central Casting registration.3
Everyone knew her by the nickname.The press used the name; the Times says there is no proof she knew it.1 3
She was killed where she was found.No blood was at the scene, indicating she was killed elsewhere.1
The case was solved and covered up.A 1949 grand jury found no police misconduct behind the failure to solve it, and the murder remains unsolved.2 6

The case also became a story about postwar L.A., and about how crime and the press feed each other. Related reading: a hotel murder case the press covered closely and another notorious Los Angeles murder case. Redding links the treatment of Short to the postwar backlash against women who had found independence in wartime jobs.3 The lead detective described her as "a tease."3

FAQ

Who killed Elizabeth Short?

Nobody knows. In October 2026 Los Angeles magazine called it one of the city's "most infamous unsolved cases."6

Where was Elizabeth Short found?

In a vacant lot on Norton Avenue near 39th Street in Leimert Park, Los Angeles, on January 15, 1947.4

Was the case ever solved?

No. Fox News and Los Angeles magazine both still described it as unsolved in 2026.5 6 A 1949 grand jury attributed the failure to a lack of evidence, not police misconduct.2

Was Elizabeth Short really an actress?

No. Press accounts called her an aspiring actress, but Harnisch says she had no acting training.3

For more unsolved Los Angeles history, see the Los Angeles hub.

Sources

  1. Federal Bureau of Investigation. "Black Dahlia." FBI History: Cases and Criminals, retrieved November 16, 2026. fbi.gov
  2. Puffer-Rothenberg, Maureen. "Black Dahlia murder." EBSCO Research Starters, Communication and Mass Media, 2019. ebsco.com
  3. Goffard, Christopher. "The Black Dahlia mystery: Wild theories, enduring myths and a long-overlooked suspect." Los Angeles Times, October 23, 2024. latimes.com
  4. Lopez, Steve. "A Startling Take on Black Dahlia Case." Los Angeles Times, April 11, 2003. latimes.com
  5. Ruiz, Michael. "Black Dahlia breakthrough: LAPD examines new fingerprint tied to victim's ex-boyfriend." Fox News, May 14, 2026. foxnews.com
  6. Conlin, Lauren. "The Black Dahlia's Autopsy Report Is Missing; Investigators Want to Know Why." Los Angeles magazine, October 7, 2026. lamag.com
  7. Federal Bureau of Investigation. "Black Dahlia (Elizabeth Short)." FBI Vault, release summary, retrieved November 18, 2026. vault.fbi.gov